Targeted Email Outreach For Agencies: Converting Email Sequences

Targeted Email Outreach For Agencies: Converting Email Sequences


Regarding marketing, agencies try out digital ads and brand collaboration to cast a wide net and hope that someone takes the plunge.

However, very few personally reach out to highly qualified clients via email. Targeted email marketing campaigns can be the marker of success when your agency is vying for attention in an overcrowded market. 

Folks at DMA tried to quantify the power of targeted email outreach, and they found that the average ROI is $55 for every dollar spent on email marketing – a shockingly good number indeed!

But email marketing isn’t only about a great ROI; successful marketers swear by cold outreach because it’s effortless to implement, scale, and analyze.

Agencies can cut costs in brand promotion and sponsorship by focusing on closing clients with targeted email campaigns. When done right, it’s capable of taking your agency to the next level. But that’s the trick here. It’s straightforward to mess up email marketing campaigns and land in the spam folders, especially for agencies that don’t track their DMARC report

In this article, we’ll lay out a 6-step targeted email marketing campaign to help your agency build a steady flow of clients and nurture a warm brand reputation and identity. 

Step 1. Find Your Leads

Research is essential to understand the market, the competitors, the clients, and even your brand. Targeted email marketing is not so different either.

Start building your ideal customer profile (ICT) to ensure your campaign hits the bullseye. Find out what companies you should target, their challenges, and how your agency can solve the problem or improve its existing business structure. 

Do you need |

Discover the most relevant agencies for your project based on your own specific requirements.

Show me agencies

After jotting down the goals, finding the people to reach out to is time. LinkedIn and Twitter are goldmines for B2B lead generation. Founders and executives often share ideas and network with folks with similar interests.

They also share their contact details which you can use to build your list. Depending on your industry, you can also find highly relevant people in Facebook groups, Discord servers, and by using Hunter’s email finder.

Targeted Email finder

However, emailing the first person you find from your target company will not lead to a response because it’s not everyone’s job to reply to cold emails.

You need to find the decision-makers in the company. Let’s assume your agency offers graphic designing services. You cannot reach out to the content editor of a company and expect a reply. You must be precise in your lead generation approach and find only the relevant people. 

Step 2. Cleaning and Segmenting Your Lead Lists

Now that you have a list, it’s time to clean it. The internet will not come up with accurate email addresses all the time.

People leave jobs, change, create new addresses, and even stop checking old inboxes. It would be best to use an email verifier to ensure your email marketing campaign isn’t filled with irrelevant or inactive addresses. It’s essential to prune lead lists because of two reasons:

  • Bounce rate: If you send emails to accounts that have been deleted or can’t receive emails right now, you’ll have a high bounce rate. The higher the bounce rate, the more likely your emails will be marked spam and stop being delivered in the future. 
  • Reputation score: An email service provider (ESP) looks at your domain and mail history to establish connections. You can’t have an account for sending emails to addresses that don’t want them. 
email verifier

After you trim your list, you need to dive deeper and segment them. Think about it – not every business needs the same graphic designing services from you. Some might need to elevate their social media game, some want to add a new element to their brand identity, or some want you to create physical billboard designs

List segmentation is the process of creating smaller groups of contacts that share the same characteristics. This can be company sizes, goals, spending capabilities, scalability, industries, etc.

You can club similar ones and tweak your cold emails to fit their needs. Segmentation is essential because it allows you to hyper-personalize your emails. 

Remember that with any of these tasks, you can outsource them to a specialized email marketing agency that can save your in-house team a lot of time.

Step 3. Writing an Email Copy

Most agencies know what a good copy can do for their website. But they rarely spend enough time perfecting their email body, especially for cold outreach. 

When it comes to writing a cold email, personalization is the key. Let’s start with the introduction.

While searching for leads, you’ll come across recent developments in their professional careers or topics they want to discuss the most. Start your email by addressing by their name and a recent activity that shows that you did your research. Hard work creates an instant impression. 

Then, tie your services to show how you can improve their business. Don’t forget that your target audience might not know who you are, so they’ll only care about what you can do for them (hence the “cold” aspect of the campaign). Always focus on them rather than you—the fewer words like ‘we’ and ‘us,’ the better. 

Keep the email short and precise. Use the inverted pyramid structure to put the most valuable content at the top. Stick to relevant messages throughout the body and end the email with a clear CTA. Leading email audiences to a particular channel is crucial; you don’t want to confuse them with multiple calls to action. 

Your email content should flow nicely, and readers must be able to skim. Keep the paragraphs short, use spaces, and add visuals, but not at the cost of making the email prominent. 

InVision’s email layout perfectly showcases how personalized email campaigns should look. The targeted message is specifically crafted for the recipient, while the visual identity and clarity of the message are on point.

Targeted Email template

Step 4. Testing Different Subject Lines

Subject lines often make or break targeted outreach emails. Subject lines are the easiest of all the things you can get wrong in an email campaign. 

Ideally, subject lines should invoke curiosity and push you to open the emails. Unfortunately, many marketers take this as a cue to make deceptive, hyperbolic, and completely irrelevant lines that are ultimately marked as spam. 

Here are two bad subject lines:

1. $100 inside! Open the email NOW!

2. Your account has been breached! Take action!

Spam filters are smart enough to see through these tactics, and as an agency, you can’t afford to see your emails going into a spam folder.

Here are some rules you need to follow:

  • Be honest, and drive straight to the point. The subject line is a small but valuable real estate
  • Invoke curiosity but with creativity. Add the value right at the front to encourage people to open the email
  • Don’t forget to experiment with emojis or punctuation marks if it fits your ICP
  • Avoid words that trigger spam filters
  • Don’t forget to utilize the preheader text box to elaborate your subject line

Swiggy combines the subject lines and the preheader texts to create irresistible emails: 

Targeted Email

Step 5. Create a Follow-up Sequence

Targeted email campaigns don’t end with sending an email to the recipient. There’s a good chance you won’t receive a reply, regardless of how great a subject line and copy you’ve used.

Cold prospects need time to warm up to cold senders; in most cases, they don’t have enough time to go through all the emails. 

A follow-up email sequence convinces leads that are not sure about your services. You can expand the core message of your first email, add new content, and attach some freebies that can help the recipient’s business.

Since most of the conversations happen after the second follow-up, it is essential to have a proper sequence. Follow-up frequency preferences vary wildly across the globe, but it’s generally acknowledged that 2-3 emails spread across 14-28 days can end up closing the deal for you

However, following up on hundreds of emails can be draining. You can automate follow-up campaigns by using an email marketing tool and adding your template, number of follow-ups, and days. It’s important to remember that you should be earnestly persuasive in your follow-ups and not intrusive or pushy. 

This follow-up email adds a touch of humor and builds upon the CTA of the previous email:

Step 6. Test Your Targeted Email Outreach Campaign

Just like many things in life, practice makes email marketing campaigns perfect. One way to practice, optimize and improve your targeted outreach sequences is by gathering data and tracking the metrics

Cold emails are not one size fits all solutions, so what works for one account might not work for the other. Subject lines are the first element you need to test. Try two variables in small batches to see which sticks and use similar ones for different accounts.

Next, tweak the email design and body to create a new visual identity. Third, play around with the CTA button to see which leads recipients to your landing page more successfully. 

By testing out different aspects of the email, including the days and times, you’ll be able to fill the gaps in your campaign and see a better response rate going forward.


Targeted email marketing campaigns allow agencies to focus on quality over quantity and close bigger deals to keep revenues soaring. The 6 step process discussed above should give you an excellent understanding of sending targeted emails that convert and bring more revenue to your agency.


Access our exclusive content!